Lucky Sun Shine
Crystals
CrystalsAbout 7 min read

How to Spot Fake and Artificial Crystals

The more expensive a crystal is, the higher the risk of encountering fakes, artificial stones, and dyed products. This beginner's guide provides a complete explanation of 8 checkpoints anyone can use to identify them, including a ranking of stones with the most fakes, places to absolutely avoid buying from, and trusted stores.

PUBLISHED
Table of Contents (Tap to toggle)

Introduction

The crystal market has a significant amount of glass fakes, dyed products, artificial stones, and treated stones in circulation. The risk is especially higher for more expensive stones, making it difficult for an amateur to tell the difference. This article will explain 8 checkpoints even beginners can use and places you should avoid buying from.

4 Categories You Should Know First

1. Natural Stones (Authentic)

Stones formed naturally deep within the earth. It's common for them to have color variations, inclusions, and tiny cracks.

These are natural stones that have undergone heat or radiation treatment to enhance their color. The majority of the Citrine market falls into this category (it's actually heat-treated Amethyst). There's no problem as long as it's clearly stated as "treated."

3. Dyed Stones (Caution Needed)

Natural stones colored with dye. Common with Lapis Lazuli, Turquoise, and Howlite. You should suspect dyeing for inexpensive items without a gemological certificate.

4. Artificial Stones and Glass Fakes (No Go)

These are complete fakes made from glass or synthetic resin. Their characteristic is that the color and patterns are too uniform.

8 Checkpoints Anyone Can Use

Check 1: Color Uniformity

  • Natural Stones: Have color variations, gradients, and impurities.
  • Fakes: The color is too uniform, and the hue is excessively vibrant.

Example: Authentic Lapis Lazuli has golden Pyrite scattered within its blue. A completely solid blue is highly likely to be dyed or fake.

Check 2: Inclusions and Cracks

  • Natural Stones: You can see small crystals, cracks, or air bubbles inside.
  • Fakes: The interior is completely clear, or air bubbles are arranged in a uniform pattern (characteristic of glass).

Stones with inclusions like the golden needles in Rutilated Quartz or the color bands in Fluorite are often easier to distinguish from fakes.

Check 3: Temperature

Natural stones feel cool to the touch. If it warms up quickly after being held in your palm for 5 seconds, it might be plastic or glass.

Check 4: Hardness (Mohs Hardness)

If you can lightly scratch it with your fingernail or a coin, it might not be the stone it claims to be.

Note: We don't recommend this check after purchase due to the risk of damaging your precious stone.

Check 5: Weight

Natural stones have solid density, so they feel heavier than fakes made of glass or resin. It's easier to tell if you compare it with an authentic stone of the same size.

Check 6: Price

  • Obviously too cheap: High probability of being fake or dyed.
  • Example: An authentic Lapis Lazuli bracelet usually costs ¥3,000 to ¥10,000, but it's being sold for ¥500.

Check 7: Store Reliability

  • Mineral specialty stores and crystal specialty stores are generally reliable.
  • Be wary of roadside stalls and souvenir shops in tourist areas.
  • Personal listings on flea market apps are not recommended unless accompanied by a gemological certificate.

Check 8: Presence of a Gemological Certificate

For expensive stones (over ¥10,000), a gemological certificate is desirable. A certificate should state:

  • Mineral name (the mineralogically accurate name)
  • Presence and type of treatment
  • Origin (may not always be stated)

Ranking of Stones with Many Fakes and Treated Items

Stones with a Particularly High Number of Fakes

  1. Lapis Lazuli: Dyed (fake dyed Howlite)
  2. Turquoise: Reconstituted and Dyed (powder pressed with resin)
  3. Malachite: A certain number of dyed products are in circulation.
  4. Amethyst: Those with overly deep color might be synthetic stones.
  5. Citrine: The majority of the market is heat-treated Amethyst (treated item).

Treatments are Common, but "Selling as Treated" is the Rule

  • Blue Topaz: Radiation treatment of colorless topaz is common.
  • Aquamarine: Heat treatment to enhance color.
  • Carnelian: Heat treatment is common.

These are legal and common as long as they are clearly stated as "natural and treated."

Places to Avoid Buying From

  • Souvenir shops in tourist areas: Price and actual quality often diverge.
  • Roadside stalls: No guarantee.
  • "Special price" online stores: Be wary of items drastically cheaper than the regular price.
  • Personal listings on flea market apps (without a gemological certificate).

Reliable Places to Buy From

  • Mineral specialty stores: Such as Ikebukuro Show Stone, Shinjuku Tokyu Hands, etc.
  • Department store jewelry sections: More expensive, but reliable.
  • Crystal specialty stores (with physical locations).
  • Mineral shows: Held several times a year, gathering specialized dealers.
  • Large online retailers: Choose stores with good reviews and a proven track record.

Editorial Team's View: "Price" is the Most Honest Signal

We've listed 8 checkpoints, but to be honest with you from the editorial team — the only reliable way for a beginner to spot fakes is by looking at the "price."

Judging color uniformity, inclusions, and temperature isn't accurate unless you're used to handling genuine stones for comparison. On the other hand, anyone can look up market prices, so by simply following the rule "don't buy anything drastically cheaper than the market price," you can avoid almost all fakes and dyed products.

Price Guidelines for 5 Stones with a High Number of Fakes and Dyed Items

StoneBracelet 8mm Market PriceSuspicious Price Range
Lapis Lazuli¥3,000 – ¥10,000Below ¥1,500 → Suspected dyed Howlite
Turquoise¥4,000 – ¥15,000Below ¥2,000 → Suspected reconstituted and dyed
Malachite¥3,000 – ¥8,000Below ¥1,500 → Suspected dyed
Jade (Genuine Jadeite)¥10,000 – Hundreds of thousandsBelow ¥3,000 → Suspected dyed or substitute stone
Morion¥3,000 – ¥8,000Below ¥1,500 → Suspected synthetic stone sold as black quartz

Products like a "¥500 Lapis bracelet" have a near 100% probability of being dyed. And dyed products, frankly, have almost zero cultural or symbolic value — that's the editorial team's honest assessment.

Before buying, check if you can answer these 5 questions:

  1. Do you know the store's location and contact information? (Be wary of online shops without a physical address.)
  2. Is the origin stated?
  3. Is the presence or absence of treatment (heat, dye, coating) clearly specified?
  4. Is it drastically cheaper compared to the market price of the same stone at other stores?
  5. Is the return policy clearly stated?

If all 5 questions are "Yes," you should be fine to buy. If even one is "No," the editorial team recommends looking at other stores a bit more.

Common Misconceptions

  • ❌ "If the store staff says it's genuine, then it's genuine." → ✅ The staff themselves might be mistaken. A gemological certificate provides objective assurance.
  • ❌ "Heat-treated items = fakes." → ✅ Heat treatment is a standard process recognized by the industry. It's legitimate if clearly stated as "treated."
  • ❌ "If it comes with a gemological certificate, it's definitely genuine." → ✅ Only if it's from a reputable gemological institution. "Certificates" created by individuals are unreliable.
  • ❌ "Mineral shows = only genuine items." → ✅ Major dealers are trustworthy, but individual booths may also have dyed products. Don't let your guard down even at shows.

A Word from Sun-chan☀️

Sometimes, people get so scared of fakes that they become afraid to buy stones at all, right?

But listen, remember this: If it's a stone you can cherish, I don't think you need to worry too much about its origin 💛

For example, even if it's a dyed stone, if your feelings from the day you bought it are infused within it, then it becomes a meaningful charm for you. Before you dismiss it as "fake and worthless," cherish the time you've spent with that little one, okay? 🌼

And next time you buy a stone, try to choose a little more carefully. Little by little, you'll start to understand what a "genuine" stone means to you! ☀️

Summary

  • Crystals fall into 4 categories: natural, treated, dyed, and fake.
  • Checks anyone can do include color uniformity, inclusions, temperature, and price.
  • For expensive stones, a gemological certificate provides peace of mind.
  • Be wary of tourist spots, roadside vendors, and individual listings on flea markets; specialty stores and mineral shows are recommended.

"Don't buy stones that are too cheap" — this is the best tip for avoiding fakes. Even if it costs a bit more, choosing one reliable stone will give you a partner you can cherish for a long time.

Tags

#Clear Quartz#Fake Stones#Buying Guide

この記事をシェアする

この記事が役に立ったら、SNSでシェアしていただけるととても嬉しいです☀️

Sun-chan

Thanks so much for reading! I hope this article brought a little sunshine to your day! See you again soon!

You might also like